Saving democracy can save the climate — and vice versa
Many distinguished Americans, including President Biden, believe that saving democracy is the most critical issue in the November election. Others think it’s the rapidly growing climate crisis. Both views are correct, because the stability of democracy and the climate are inextricably connected.
Scores of American thought leaders — scientists, writers, former government officials and environmental activists — made that point last week in a statement published in the Washington Post. (In the interest of full disclosure, I am one of the signers, and the Presidential Climate Action Project is one of the ad's sponsors.) The statement points out that we can’t conquer climate change without a healthy democracy, and we can’t sustain democracy without conquering global warming. Let’s break it down.
Democracy is necessary because, as we have seen over the last 70 years shows, only voters can overcome the power of the fossil energy industry.
The record shows that elements of the oil industry knew in the 1950s that their products were causing global warming. The government's top climate scientist briefed Congress in 1988 that warming already was evident in the U.S.
In 1992, the Senate blessed, and President George H.W. Bush signed, the first international climate treaty, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. It promised the U.S. would work with the rest of the world to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions. But Congress has failed ever since to take the most decisive action. In 2003 and again in 2008, it failed to pass bills to put a price on carbon emissions, a step economists agreed was the most effective solution.
In 2006, President George W. Bush, a former Texas oil man, famously declared that "America is addicted to oil." Yet despite repeated attempts by Presidents Barack Obama and Joe Biden, Congress has refused to stop subsidizing this drug. Fossil fuels have received taxpayer subsidies for over a century; they still get tens of billions of taxpayer dollars yearly.
All these years later, despite all the warnings of climate science, fossil fuels still provide more than 80 percent of America's energy. And after dipping during the pandemic, America's greenhouse gas emissions increased by 5.7 percent from 2020 to 2022.
In 2022, Congress passed legislation filled with carrots for clean energy, but no sticks for fossil fuels. In fact, the Inflation Reduction Act only passed Congress because of several concessions to fossil fuels. The history is testimony to the industry’s political power.
And in recent years, the U.S. Supreme Court has made it even more powerful, by ruling in 2010 (Citizens United v. FEC) that corporations and wealthy individuals can give unlimited amounts of money to political campaigns and constraining the government's ability to regulate pollution at national scale (West Virginia v. EPA in 2022, Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council in 2024).
Today, 123 Republicans in the current Congress still deny that climate change is real or human-caused. And the Republican nominee for president still contends that climate change is a hoax.
It’s clear that the voting muscle of individual Americans can overcome the power of the oil, gas and coal industries. Unfortunately, voters have not yet risen to the challenge by keeping climate deniers out of public office.
So, what about the converse — the threat climate change poses to democracy? When problems beset a nation and leaders fail to help solve them, people lose faith in government. As 2024 began, Gallup reported that only 28 percent of American adults were happy with the way democracy is working.
But today’s unsolved problems are nothing compared to what’s ahead if climate change is not effectively addressed. TIME senior correspondent Justin Worland puts it well: "The challenges created by climate change — unchecked migration, economic stagnation, and the loss of homeland, to name a few — are precisely the kind of developments that have historically fomented authoritarian sentiments."
Today's immigration problem is merely a sample of what's to come as climate impacts escalate. The Brennan Center notes that the disturbing scenes on our southern border are "a stark reminder that both political parties need to seriously reckon with an issue that will only become more prominent as the climate crisis exacerbates the conditions which push people to migrate to the United States." Researchers estimate that in the most extreme future, more than 30 million climate migrants will seek refuge in the U.S. over the next 30 years.
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration reports that "changes in our climate and our oceans are having very real and profound effects on communities, businesses, and the natural resources we depend on." The U.S. Treasury Department says climate inflation already affects household finances nationwide, with 13 percent of Americans reporting economic hardship due to climate-related disasters.
Other researchers note that climate change is pushing up consumer prices worldwide. They predict food prices will rise as much as 1.8 percent annually within a decade, causing overall inflation to increase by nearly 1 percent yearly.
Deloitte, the prominent management consultant, notes that, on our present course, climate change will slow economic growth worldwide, creating losses of up to $178 trillion due to declines in productivity, jobs, standards of living and well-being. The most vulnerable industries are agriculture, conventional energy, manufacturing, transportation and construction, the company says.
Defense and security analysts have warned for years that climate change threatens international and domestic security. In 2008, the National Intelligence Assessment warned, "Climate change will have wide-ranging implications for U.S. national security interests over the next 20 years." The Department of Homeland Security cautioned in 2012 that climate impacts could directly affect America's critical infrastructure.
The highly regarded medical journal Lancet reports that air pollution from fossil fuels kills 1.2 million people worldwide yearly, including 11,800 in the U.S. "Our health is at the mercy of fossil fuels," according to Marina Romanello, executive director of Lancet's annual report on health and climate change.
Worland correctly concludes, "Something needs to change so that the policy timeline in democracies can match the urgency of the climate crisis."
In their statement in the Washington Post, the signers note, "Both the assault on democracy and climate chaos are on the ballot in 2024. They are converging crises that threaten to destroy our common future....Without an engaged, competent, and supportive citizenry — the 'mighty reservoir of experience, knowledge, beauty, love and deed' — no government can cope with the full effects of a destabilizing climate."
It's true that the U.S. cannot solve the climate crisis alone, but the world can't solve the climate crisis without the U.S. So, as voters check the boxes on their ballots two months from now, they will decide two interrelated questions: "Will America’s future be stable and secure?" and "Can government by the people long endure?
William S. Becker is executive director of the Presidential Climate Action Project and a former senior official at the U.S. Department of Energy.
Date: | |
Tag: | Climate |
-
BBC News - Top stories
Publishers try skinnier books to save money and emissions
Subtle changes to the font can make books much slimmer and lighter - saving money and CO2 emissions.4 hours ago -
ABC News - Sports
Manzardo homers, Clase gets 46th save as Guardians rally past Twins 4-3 to tighten grip on Central
Rookie Kyle Manzardo hit a two-run, go-ahead homer in the eighth inning and Emmanuel Clase recorded his 46th save as the Cleveland Guardians rallied to beat the Minnesota Twins 4-3 to tighten their ...17 minutes ago - MLB -
ABC News - World
Democracy declined for 8th straight year around the globe, institute finds
An organization promoting democracy says last year had the worst decline in credible elections and parliamentary oversight in almost a half-century3 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
Who will Japan’s next PM be? A policy wonk, ultra-conservative or surfer making the climate fight ‘sexy’
Polls show Shigeru Ishiba, Sanae Takaichi and Shinji Koizumi are best placed to replace PM Fumio Kishida later this month. With just 10 days to go before Japan ’s governing party elects a new ...3 hours ago - Climate -
ABC News - World
Former Canadian vice admiral found not guilty of sexually assaulting a sailor on a ship in 1991
A former Canadian vice admiral has been found not guilty of sexual assault and an indecent act over his behavior on a ship during a 1991 deployment25 minutes ago -
CBS News - Top stories
What can revive the American starter home?
Only one-third of American families can afford a starter home in just 10 of the 100 largest cities in the U.S., CBS News found.3 hours ago -
CNBC - Business
New details of Trump family crypto project released, including who can buy in
World Liberty Financial is expected to operate as a crypto banking platform.34 minutes ago - Donald Trump
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Hillary Clinton condemns 'terrible' Trump assassination attempt, but he should try to 'calm the waters'
Hillary Clinton says she reacted in "horror" to the second apparent assassination attempt against Donald Trump, calling it a "terrible thing," but denounced the former president for continuing to ...49 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
GOP lawmaker suggests Trump may need to look at private security
Rep. Russ Fulcher (R-Idaho) suggested on Monday former President Trump consider hiring private security following the second apparent assassination attempt in the last few months. “If I'm President ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Sean 'Diddy' Combs arrested in New York: Reports
The hip-hop mogul is set to appear in federal court at 10 a.m. ET Tuesday, sources tell NewsNation.1 hour ago - New York -
The Hill - Politics
Trump says crypto is 'fledging' yet ‘massive business’ in project launch
Former President Trump and his sons unveiled new details about their new cryptocurrency platform World Liberty Financial on Monday night, marking the former president’s latest embrace of digital ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Trump recounts being on golf course during apparent assassination attempt
Former President Trump on Monday offered his first recollection of what he was doing when Secret Service engaged an alleged would-be-assassin along the perimeter of his Florida golf club a day ...2 hours ago - Donald Trump